← All Practice Guides

AI tools and safe use

AI scribes: the checklist before your first consult

What an NZ practice should sort out before anyone presses record on an AI scribe, from patient consent to checking each note and getting the vendor's answers in writing.

Last checked 17 November 2026 Β· First published 17 November 2026 Β· 4 min read

Written by Dr Ryo Eguchi, an Auckland GP and founder of ClinicPro, which makes ClinicPro Capture (clinical photos into Medtech) and other tools for NZ practices. ClinicPro is mentioned in this guide only where it genuinely fits. Our fairness policy.

Before anyone presses record, sort these out. Each one comes from something the GP College, the Medical Council, ACC, the Privacy Commissioner or Health NZ has already said. Where a detail is our own suggestion, the article says so.

Why doctors use them

Most people think of a scribe as a time saver. Some doctors who use one describe a lighter mental load: not having to remember the whole consult to type up afterwards, and more attention left for the patient. The senior doctors' union, ASMS, told its members that senior doctors using it in emergency departments had reported it "eased cognitive pressure", and Health NZ says clinicians report being able to focus more on patient care (RNZ, March 2026).

What the GP College says

We couldn't find any scribe guidance of the College's own. It has endorsed the Medical Council's March 2026 guidance on AI in patient care, which covers scribes by name. The consent and note-checking sections below follow it.

In its submission on the draft guidance, the College said:

  • GPs should be ready to explain what the tool records and who can see it.
  • Practices bringing in AI tools are responsible for checking they're ethical, reliable and accurate.
  • Māori have the right to control their data, with an emphasis on keeping it in New Zealand.

The patient agrees first, and you note it

The Medical Council's March 2026 guidance lists "using an AI tool to record the consultation, such as a transcription tool (scribe)" as a situation that needs informed consent.

Decide beforehand what happens if a patient says no (our suggestion). Then tell each patient how their care changes if they do, get their answer, and press record. Always note in their record whether they agreed.

The doctor checks every note before it goes in

In the Council's words: "AI is not a substitute for your clinical judgement, and you remain responsible for all your clinical decisions and actions."

As far as is reasonably practicable, the doctor checks the draft is accurate before it goes in the record.

The vendor answers in writing

With a third-party tool, the practice remains responsible for protecting patient information, the Privacy Commissioner says. Get these answers on paper before signing (our suggestion):

  • Is our data used to train anything? The Commissioner asks this, and ACC says it shouldn't happen.
  • Where is it stored and processed? The Council says the tool must not share patient-identifiable information outside the care setting.
  • How long are audio and transcripts kept? The Commissioner's 2023 generative AI guidance says to make sure the tool doesn't keep or pass on personal information.

Check which version you're on, too. ACC's position statement tells its providers to use only tools that have been assessed and purchased. Health NZ's review of Heidi doesn't permit the free version within Health NZ, because it doesn't meet Health NZ's privacy, security or contractual standards.

If a vendor says Health NZ endorses them, ask for the written review. Those reviews cover use within Health NZ, so they probably don't cover your practice.

What others are saying

  • Medical Protection, the medical defence organisation, says its help with AI matters, which is discretionary, depends on a human staying the decision maker. It expects members to have clear AI policies, including when to get consent, and excludes claims from data loss or breaches.
  • The NZ College of Midwives wants consent explicitly for each consultation, and midwives to know how long audio and transcripts are kept.
  • Dr Sylvia Boys, vice-president of the senior doctors' union (ASMS), told RNZ a scribe can misread what's happening during an examination, and can struggle to keep two patients apart when it hears both.
  • Health NZ said feedback from 40 clinicians surveyed showed a need to "further improve accuracy and reduce editing effort" (RNZ, March 2026).

In short

A scribe can take the typing off your hands, but the note is still yours. Get the patient's agreement, check every note, and know where the recording goes. The checklists below sum it up.

Checklist

Before you start using a scribe
☐ The vendor has answered in writing: training, where data sits, how long it's kept
☐ A paid or contracted version, not a free account
☐ You've decided what happens when a patient says no
Every consultation
☐ Tell the patient how their care changes if they say no, and get their answer
☐ Note in the record whether they agreed
☐ Check the note before it's saved, as far as is reasonably practicable

Sources

  1. RNZCGP, College endorsed documentsβ€œThis MCNZ guidance explains what doctors should consider when using AI in patient care.”
  2. RNZCGP, submission to the Medical Council on using AI in patient care (1 October 2025)β€œspecialist GPs should be prepared to discuss, what information the AI technology will record and who may have access to it”
  3. Medical Council of New Zealand, Guidance on using AI in patient care (published 10 March 2026)β€œusing an AI tool to record the consultation, such as a transcription tool (scribe)”
  4. ACC, Working with AI in healthcare, a position statement for ACC-registered health providers (March 2026)β€œHealth providers should never use client and/or ACC data with freely available public AI tools”
  5. Office of the Privacy Commissioner, Generative Artificial Intelligence (15 June 2023)β€œOnly use a generative AI tool after conducting a Privacy Impact Assessment”
  6. Office of the Privacy Commissioner, Artificial intelligence and the Information Privacy Principles (September 2023)β€œyou remain responsible for protecting that information”
  7. Health NZ, AI scribe usage OIA HNZ00203404 (published 25 June 2026)β€œNAIAEAG endorses further piloting and evaluation of the Heidi Health solution within Health NZ.”
  8. Medical Protection, New position on AI and robotics in healthcare (3 December 2025)β€œMembers should have clear policies relating to the use of AI, including when patient consent should be obtained.”
  9. NZ College of Midwives, AI consensus statement (updated October 2026)β€œmust be explicitly obtained prior to their use for each consultation”
  10. RNZ, AI scribe tool being used in emergency departments (28 February 2026)β€œAI can sometimes misinterpret what is going on”
  11. RNZ via Scoop, Emergency doctors estimate AI scribe Heidi saving up to 10 minutes per patient (17 March 2026)β€œfurther improve accuracy and reduce editing effort”

Spotted a mistake or something out of date? Email ryo@clinicpro.co.nz. See our fairness policy.